• About Me
  • Customers
    • Repair Shop
    • Sopp

Alexander Vondrous

echo "Hello Word!"

Month: December 2013

A Paper Review

16. December 2013 by sasa Leave a Comment

The paper I was worried about suggesting good referees is now accepted with minor changes at the 1st try. It took 1 month an 10 days. This is my second accepted paper as main author  and the fastest review I have seen in the institute.

The referees comments are very positive and increase the quality of the manuscript and caused a positive mind set. I wonder if I should thank the referees and put there names on the paper. Ups Its a single-blind review process. So thank you, mysterious scientist.

Another interesting thing are the different reviewer comment styles. I only have a small sample set of two measurement points but it shows already an extreme gap. Some referees directly like what they see and only comment on major issues. Some referees are giving many very detailed hints.

Example
Referee #1: I recommend the paper for publication. END
Referee #2: <2 sections introduciton> <many hints> I recommend the paper for publication, with some changes.
Referee #3: What is this piece of crap
Referee #4: -no comment-  (?died during review?)

The example illustrates a 2:1 win, which would result in an accepted paper with some changes.

Posted in: Allgemein Tagged: paper, referees, review, science

Recent Posts

  • Scary Halloween Lights
  • Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • PhD Survival Kit
  • Ready, Steady, GOOOOO
  • Software Chindogu

Archives

  • October 2018
  • August 2018
  • August 2015
  • March 2015
  • May 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013

Recent Comments

  • MT Varghese on About Me
  • Tom Zimmerman on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • sasa on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • Tom Zimmerman on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday

Recent Posts

  • Scary Halloween Lights
  • Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • PhD Survival Kit
  • Ready, Steady, GOOOOO
  • Software Chindogu

Archives

  • October 2018
  • August 2018
  • August 2015
  • March 2015
  • May 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013

Recent Comments

  • MT Varghese on About Me
  • Tom Zimmerman on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • sasa on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday
  • Tom Zimmerman on Indication to Celebrate Birth as Most Important Birthday

Copyright © 2021 Alexander Vondrous.

Omega WordPress Theme by ThemeHall